Welcome to New York Vinny’s Pizza 🍕
If you’re searching for the best pizza place in town, New York Vinny’s Pizza is where real pizza meets real fast! With two locations in Lacey and Federal Way, we’re proud to serve pizzas made fresh, fast, and full of flavor. Whether you’re picking up a quick lunch, grabbing dinner for the family, or ordering in for movie night, we make it easy to enjoy your favorite pizza whenever and wherever you want.
Made Fresh, Served Fast, Always Delicious!
At New York Vinny’s, we keep it simple — real pizza made fresh and fast. Each pie is crafted with quality dough, rich sauce, and real cheese, never shortcuts. Choose from classics like pepperoni or try our loaded specialty pizzas, all served hot and ready for takeout or delivery. Craving more? Add wings with bold sauces, fresh salads, or cheesy calzones. Every order is made fresh and full of flavor, perfect for one or a crowd.
Order From Our Website
Skip the wait and bring New York Vinny's Pizza straight to your table. Order online through our website for pickup or delivery and enjoy your favorites with just a few clicks.
Crave-Worthy Bites That Speak for Themselves
Every dish at New York Vinny’s is made fresh and served hot, packed with the perfect mix of flavor and texture. From golden crusts to savory sides, each bite brings the kind of quality and freshness you can count on every time.
Catering That Brings the Party
We’re all about celebrating at New York Vinny’s! Whether it’s a small get-together of 20 or a crowd of 200, our catering makes it easy to keep everyone happy. Choose from a variety of our signature pizzas and sides like wings, salads, cheesy bread, and desserts. When New York Vinny’s is on the table, you can count on everyone being ready to party. Just place your order and we’ll handle the rest — it’s that simple!
Visit Us Today
You can find us at 8205 Martin Way East, Lacey, WA 98516, and 2132 Southwest 336th Street, Federal Way, WA 98023. Stop by either location and see why we’re known as the best pizza place in town. With friendly service, fresh ingredients, and fast turnaround, New York Vinny’s Pizza is your go-to spot for great food and good times. Order today and get a slice of real pizza, real fast!
What our guests are saying
Vinny's Pizza is an absolute gem in the area, serving up a delectable array of pizzas that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. From their perfect crust to the generous toppings, each bite is a symphony of flavors that is simply unmatched. With their unparalleled attention to detail and commitment to quality, it's no wonder they've earned the reputation for having the best pizza in town, hands down.
Dave D.
I got 2 pizzas to go. My first time trying pizza from here. I ordered the Vinny's combo. I really like the crust and the toppings were great. One of my favorites now.
Steve D.
The food is Fantastic as well as very affordable. I really enjoy the way that no matter when I order, it is always the same. Consistency. The staff is always very friendly and ready to make suggestions for you. Service is always exactly how it should be. Quick, polite and accurate. Customer for life
Justin K.
Featuring
Take Out
Delivery
Catering
New York Vinny's Pizza Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Taco Pizza, Vegetarian Food, Caesar Salad, New York Pizza, Supreme Pizza, Italian Food, Veggie Pizza, Buffalo Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, Salads, Wings, Cheesecake, Meatballs, and Calzone
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Federal Way, Lacey, Tanglewilde, Thompson Place, Union Mill, Mirror Lake, Adelaide, Buenna, Lakota, Dash Point, Saint Clair, Fife Heights, Nisqually, Caledonia, Browns Point, Beachcrest, Redondo, Lakeland South, Milton, South Bay.
