Best Pizza in Federal Way

Real Ingredients, Bold Flavor, Served Fast Every Time!

We’re Located in Federal Way, WA

Located in the heart of the Twin Lakes neighborhood, our Federal Way location is at 2132 Southwest 336th Street, Federal Way, WA 98023, making it a convenient stop for locals and visitors alike. We’re just minutes from Wild Waves Theme & Water Park, perfect for family fun, and close to West Hylebos Wetlands and Dash Point State Park for outdoor adventures. Easily accessible from across Federal Way, we proudly serve the surrounding community.

Find Us

Featured

View menu

Welcome to New York Vinny’s Pizza

Address: 2132 Southwest 336th Street, Federal Way, WA 98023 Phone: +1 253-344-1499 Hours: Monday 11 AM–9 PM Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM Thursday 11 AM–9 PM Friday 11 AM–9:30 PM Saturday 11 AM–9:30 PM Sunday 11 AM–9 PM

Get Directions

Made Fresh, Served Fast, Always Delicious!

At New York Vinny’s, we keep it simple — real pizza made fresh and fast. Each pie is crafted with quality dough, rich sauce, and real cheese, never shortcuts. Choose from classics like pepperoni or try our loaded specialty pizzas, all served hot and ready for takeout or delivery. Craving more? Add wings with bold sauces, fresh salads, or cheesy calzones. Every order is made fresh and full of flavor, perfect for one or a crowd.

Explore Our Menu

Favorite Local Spot with Excellent Quality

Customers consistently praise our Federal Way location as the “best pizza” spot in the area, thanks to bold flavors, a perfectly baked crust, and fresh, high-quality ingredients. Patrons return again and again, highlighting both the excellent taste and great value. Known for reliable, satisfying meals every visit, our restaurant has earned a loyal following and continues to impress with consistently positive reviews across the community.

Order From Our Website

Skip the wait and bring New York Vinny's Pizza straight to your table. Order online through our website for pickup or delivery and enjoy your favorites with just a few clicks.

Order Now

Crave-Worthy Bites That Speak for Themselves

Every dish at New York Vinny’s is made fresh and served hot, packed with the perfect mix of flavor and texture. From golden crusts to savory sides, each bite brings the kind of quality and freshness you can count on every time.

Catering That Brings the Party

We’re all about celebrating at New York Vinny’s! Whether it’s a small get-together of 20 or a crowd of 200, our catering makes it easy to keep everyone happy. Choose from a variety of our signature pizzas and sides like wings, salads, cheesy bread, and desserts. When New York Vinny’s is on the table, you can count on everyone being ready to party. Just place your order and we’ll handle the rest — it’s that simple!

Cater With Us

Visit Us Today at Federal Way Location!

You can find us at 2132 Southwest 336th Street, Federal Way, WA 98023. Stop by and see why we’re known as the best pizza place in town. With friendly service, fresh ingredients, and fast turnaround, New York Vinny’s Pizza is your go-to spot for great food and good times. Order today and get a slice of real pizza, real fast!

Find Us

What our guests are saying

My first time here and I loved it. The pizza is delicious and the girls that work there were so nice. 100% recommend.

Ale G.

As someone who works in fast food and has to prepare orders quickly, I was impressed by the speed and care of my order. It was in and out for me, and I couldn't have it any other way. The employees acted nicely, and the place inside looked nice for the time I was there. And on the drive home, the smell was great; I couldn't wait until I got home. Thank you, employees of Vinny's.

Jonathan R.

Growing up on the East Coast in Massachusetts and having pizza all across the USA, living in Chicago and California. I can definitely say that NY Vinny's pizza is the best I've had West of the East Coast which is amazing to find that authentic and delicious style out here!